Yorktown/Mt. Pleasant Historical Alliance and Museum

1974 Top Hat Fire

On May 13, 1974, the Top Hat restaurant on St. Rd. 32 between Yorktown and Daleville was destroyed by fire.  The hundred-year-old building was once the home of Judge David Kilgore. In the 1930s, the home was converted into a restaurant. It was a popular location for dances, proms, reunions, and holidays.

In 1974, at the time of the fire, the building was leased by Robert and Pat Huffman but was owned by Arthur and Jane Olsen of Glenwood, IL. Jane is the great-granddaughter of David Kilgore.

The Top Hat was Once the Home of Judge David Kilgore

Inside the To[ Hat From: Kay Ross Miller

1917 I.O.O.F. Independent Order of Odd Fellows

Posted by James Romack, Facebook, Yorktown Indiana Historical Alliance

1917 I.O.O.F. Lodge 345, The lodge was rebuilt after the block was partially burned after a fire in 1913. You can see a garage on the corner. The gas pump is just on the other side of the car. A barbershop is two doors down.

The Yorktown Mt. Pleasant Historical Alliance and Museum occupies the space below the I.O.O.F. in downtown Yorktown. (2021) We want to thank the I.O.O.F for their generous support of the Alliance and Museum.

The stated purpose of the I.O.O.F. is: to improve and elevate the character of mankind by promoting the principles of friendship, love, truth, faith, hope, charity and universal justice.

Looking from Walnut to the northeast side of Smith Street

Another view of the gas pump

Hullabaloo Scene

Hullabaloo Scene Sign
The 1967 Hullabaloo Scene Sign

The Hullabaloo was a dance club for teenagers 14-18, on November 17, 1967. It was near the corner of Highway 32 and Andrews Road, east of Yorktown.

The club was owned by Larry A Robertson, David E. Robertson, and Jeffry Carter. Dance lessons were taught by Mari Brown and Jamie Lee.

Yorktown Railroad Depot

At one time passenger trains came through Yorktown four times a day. The Interurban street cars came even more frequently but those tracks ran down the middle of Smith St. and did not leave from this depot. You could ride to most major cities from Yorktown. The man standing in front of the depot is Charles Mann.

In-Law Lake

Posted in 2020 by Elaine Williams, Facebook, Yorktown Indiana Historical Alliance

In-Law Lake cabin ruins circa 1975

Posted 2020 by Larry Broadwater, Facebook, Yorktown Indiana Historical Alliance

Tourist cabins at In-Law lake circa 1975